top of page

Heritage Cookie Collection

Rooted in tradition and made from scratch, the Heritage Cookie Collection reflects the recipes, techniques, and care that shaped my kitchen long before Cooking With Carmen had a name. These cookies are simple on purpose, focused on texture, balance, and honest flavor, just like they were made generations ago. Every batch carries history, heart, and the kind of comfort that never goes out of style.



From the Family Recipe Box

From the Family Recipe Box

Timeless recipes, baked with intention and passed down with pride.




Old Fashioned Tea Cake Cookies

These tea cakes are made from my great-grandmother’s recipe, the kind that lived in handwritten notes, memory, and muscle instinct. Simple ingredients. No shortcuts. Soft, lightly sweet, and gently crisp around the edges, just as they were meant to be. Nothing fancy. Nothing modern. Just tradition, passed down and baked the same way it always has been—because some things don’t need improving. Sold by the dozen

$25

Old Fashioned Tea Cake Cookies


Homemade Classic Short Bread Cookies

These handcrafted shortbread cookies are made the traditional way, real butter, simple ingredients, and careful attention to technique. Each cookie is delicately crisp on the outside, impossibly tender at the center, and melts the moment it touches your tongue. There’s no shortcut here, just patience, balance, and respect for a recipe that’s stood the test of time. This is the kind of shortbread that doesn’t need icing, drizzle, or distraction. It speaks for itself with rich flavor, clean finish, and old-world elegance. Perfect alongside coffee or tea or savored quietly when you want something truly special. Sold by the dozen Handmade • Small-batch • Premium butter-based recipe

$28

Homemade Classic Short Bread Cookies


Chocolate-Dipped Pistachio Shortbread Cookies

A buttery, melt-in-your-mouth shortbread cookie made with finely chopped pistachios baked directly into the dough for rich, nutty depth in every bite. Each cookie is finished with a smooth milk chocolate dip and an extra sprinkle of pistachios for balance, texture, and visual appeal. A classic shortbread, elevated with intention, technique, and restraint. Sold by the dozen

$36

Chocolate-Dipped Pistachio Shortbread Cookies


Double Chocolate Chip Cookie

These are not your average chocolate chip cookies. Each one starts with a rich, buttery dough and is generously loaded with double the chocolate, melty chocolate chips and chunks tucked into every bite. Soft in the center, lightly crisp around the edges, and deeply satisfying, these cookies deliver bold chocolate flavor without being heavy or overdone. Baked fresh, indulgent, and made to remind you why the classics never go out of style. Sold by the dozen.

$28

Double Chocolate Chip Cookie


Ginger Snaps

Soft and chewy ginger snap cookies rich with deep molasses and warming spices, delivering that signature ginger-spiced bite in every mouthful. Bold, comforting, and unapologetically nostalgic, no need to wait for fall or winter to enjoy these classics. Sold by the dozen

$22

Ginger Snaps


White Chocolate Cranberry Pecan Cookies

Soft-baked and generously loaded, these cookies strike the perfect balance of sweet, tart, and nutty. Creamy white chocolate melts into every bite, complemented by bursts of dried cranberries and buttery toasted pecans. Rich, comforting, and thoughtfully made, this is a cookie that feels special, not seasonal. Sold by the dozen.

$30

White Chocolate Cranberry Pecan Cookies

bottom of page